Pasta, pizza & red-sauce classics
Orlando's Italian scene runs from candlelit pasta counters to checkered-tablecloth red-sauce rooms and wood-fired pizza worth crossing town for. This guide skips the ranking and sorts the city's best Italian restaurants by the kind of night you're after: a handmade-pasta date, a special-occasion dinner, a big family table or a pizza weeknight. It also maps where each one sits, from Thornton Park and Winter Park to Dr. Phillips and I-Drive.
Where to book the anniversary dinner.
Michelin Recommended · New for 2026 Chef Michael Cooper cooks classic Italian-American food with a modern hand, chicken parm included, in a stylish Thornton Park dining room. It joined the MICHELIN Guide for 2026. Dinner runs Tuesday through Saturday, with brunch on Sunday.
Known for: Gnocco fritto, truffle arancini, bucatini diabolo, butterscotch budino
Michelin Recommended Chef Brandon McGlamery's Park Avenue restaurant cooks seasonal Italian-American food, from house-made pastas to wood-fired pizzas whose toppings change with the menu. The room has vaulted ceilings, exposed brick and caramel-leather booths around a central bar.
Known for: Wood-fired pizzas, pumpkin arancini, house-made pasta
Michelin Recommended Two-time James Beard Award winner Melissa Kelly runs this farm-to-table Italian dining room inside the JW Marriott Orlando, Grande Lakes. Produce, honey and eggs come from the on-site Primo Garden and nearby Florida farms.
Michelin Recommended The Italian restaurant at Four Seasons Resort Orlando, with a leafy terrace and a menu of small plates, pizzas, house-made pastas and larger mains. Executive chef Fabrizio Schenardi works in family recipes, like his grandmother's spinach, veal and ricotta ravioli.
Known for: Spinach, veal and ricotta ravioli; house-made limoncello
Northern Italian cooking and polished service in the dining room at Loews Portofino Bay Hotel, a boat ride from the Universal parks. It's dinner only, nightly from 5:30 PM, and resort or business-casual dress is recommended.
For when the pasta is the point.
Editor's Pick A family-owned Italian restaurant on South Park Avenue that makes its pasta fresh every day. It opened in 2025 and serves lunch and dinner daily.
Known for: Burrata with caramelized pear, carbonara, paccheri al ragù
A College Park pasta restaurant on Edgewater Drive built around fresh pasta and sauces made in-house every day. It's open for dinner nightly and from noon on Sundays.
Turci Pasta's sister restaurant sits a few steps off Park Avenue on Morse Boulevard, pairing house-made pasta with heartier plates like lamb shank over saffron risotto. There's outdoor seating, too.
Known for: Lasagna, lamb shank over saffron risotto
Big plates, big tables, no pretense.
A seafood-focused Italian spot on a quiet stretch of North Primrose Drive, with wood-paneled walls and generous portions. Order the linguine ai frutti di mare, with mussels, shrimp, scallops and calamari in a garlicky tomato sauce. Closed Sundays.
Known for: Linguine ai frutti di mare, cioppino
Italian-born owner Rocco Potami runs this intimate dining room in a 1940s building on US 17-92. Sauces are made from scratch, and the menu takes in dishes from across Italy.
A Maitland favorite in two parts. Upstairs, the dining room overlooks Lake Lily and serves Northern and coastal Italian seafood, veal, steaks and pasta. Downstairs is a casual café and market stocked with imported Italian groceries and wine.
Restaurant Row's old-school Italian since 1984, with waiters in black suits and bow ties and an accordionist working the room. It's open for dinner seven nights a week and suits a night of entertaining.
Known for: 32-ounce veal chop, house-made pasta
Wood-fired, Neapolitan-style and the neighborhood slice.
Michelin Recommended A strip-mall pizzeria on Curry Ford Road with a wood-fired oven and creative Neapolitan-style pies, like the Lover Boy Blue with blueberries, bacon, fontina and honey. Start with the meatballs or garlic knobs.
Known for: Lover Boy Blue pizza, meatballs, garlic knobs
A neighborhood Italian kitchen where wood-fired pizza is the house specialty, backed by pastas and salads. The original location moved into its own building at Primrose Drive and Curry Ford Road in 2023.
Known for slices as big as your face and whole pies 30 inches across. The Mills 50 shop on East Colonial Drive is one of three, with others near UCF and in Maitland.
A small, family-run Winter Park pizzeria on West Fairbanks Avenue, making New York-style pies with plenty of garlic, marinara and herbs. Seating is limited, so it works best for takeout.
Better-than-chain options near the parks and the convention center.
An Italian-leaning steakhouse on International Drive that grills over a Florida citrus and oak fire. Steaks are aged on site, and the wine list runs past 500 bottles.
A locally owned Italian restaurant minutes from ICON Park and the convention center. The menu runs from house-made gnocchi and chicken parmigiana to veal ossobuco and steaks, and there is a kids menu.
Known for: House-made gnocchi, veal ossobuco, tiramisu
Inspired by the owner's grandmother from Naples, with house-made pastas and Sicilian-style square pizzas from an 800-degree brick oven. Weekend brunch runs 11 AM to 3 PM, and it stays open late.
A family-owned Northern Italian restaurant on Turkey Lake Road, a short drive from Universal, known for handmade pastas and wood-fired pizzas. It's in a strip mall, but the dining room is warm and well appointed.
Known for: Gnocchi al pesto, bucatini amatriciana, wood-oven pizza
A lakeside villa, small-town dining rooms and wood-fired pies, each a short drive out of the city.
A family-founded restaurant built like an Italian villa on the shore of Lake Fairy in Longwood, open since 1980. It's a special-occasion pick, with wine dinners through the year.
Editor's Pick A wood-fired pizzeria on SR 436 in Altamonte Springs where the sauces, pestos, pastas and desserts are all made in-house. Lunch is counter-style with QR-code ordering; dinner, Tuesday through Saturday, brings table service and reservations.
Known for: Wood-fired pizza, house-made pasta and pesto
An Italian market and restaurant on Tremaine Street in downtown Winter Garden, built around a wood-fired oven. Build your own pizza or order from a menu of salads and homemade desserts, with craft cocktails and brunch pizzas on weekends.
Known for: Build-your-own wood-fired pizza, brunch pizzas, cannoli
Chef Gianni Liverotti grew up outside Rome and came to Central Florida to cook at Disney before opening this two-story restaurant in downtown Mount Dora. The pasta is homemade; look for his sacchettini, little pasta purses filled with pear.
Known for: Homemade pasta, sacchettini (pear-filled pasta purses)
Menus follow the market and a region's habits: smaller plates, sauces that coat rather than pool, and pasta served as its own course. Ravello and Primo cook this way.
Born in immigrant kitchens in the U.S.: bigger portions, long-simmered tomato sauce and family-style tables. Osteria Ester and Prato give it a modern polish; the red-sauce classics keep it hearty.
Search by name or filter by neighborhood. Each name opens its full directory listing.
No restaurants match. Clear the search or a neighborhood filter.
New neighborhood roundups and Orlando dining guides in your inbox. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Five Orlando-area Italian and pizza restaurants are Recommended in the 2026 MICHELIN Guide Florida: Osteria Ester in Thornton Park (new for 2026), Prato in Winter Park, Pizza Bruno on Curry Ford Road, Primo by Melissa Kelly at Grande Lakes and Ravello at Four Seasons Resort Orlando. None of them holds a Michelin star or a Bib Gourmand.
Start with Turci Pasta on Edgewater Drive in College Park and its sister restaurant Luca Turci in Winter Park, Grappolo Cucina Italiana on Park Avenue, which makes its pasta fresh daily, and Osteria Ester in Thornton Park. Prato and Ravello also make their own pasta.
For a special night, book Osteria Ester, Prato, Primo by Melissa Kelly, Ravello or Bice Ristorante. Enzo's on the Lake in Longwood sits on the shore of Lake Fairy, and Antonio's upstairs dining room in Maitland overlooks Lake Lily.
On International Drive, try Vito's Chop House, Vincenzo Cucina Italiana or Mia's Italian Kitchen. Fresco Cucina Italiana is on Turkey Lake Road near Universal, and Bice Ristorante is inside Loews Portofino Bay Hotel. Near Disney, Ravello is at Four Seasons Resort Orlando, and Primo is at the JW Marriott at Grande Lakes.
The red-sauce classics: Il Pescatore on North Primrose Drive, Rocco's Italian Grille & Bar in Winter Park, Antonio's in Maitland and Christini's on Restaurant Row. Vincenzo Cucina Italiana on I-Drive has a kids menu.
For dinner at the sit-down restaurants, book ahead, especially on weekends. Osteria Ester, Grappolo, Luca Turci, Primo, Christini's, Vito's Chop House, Vincenzo and Enzo's on the Lake all take reservations on OpenTable, and Grappolo also seats walk-ins on its patio and at the bar.
Pizza Bruno on Curry Ford Road is the area's MICHELIN-Recommended pizzeria, known for creative Neapolitan-style pies from a wood-fired oven. F&D Woodfired Italian Kitchen is close by in the Hourglass District, Lazy Moon in Mills 50 sells famously giant slices, and Antonella's in Winter Park makes New York-style pies. Prato also turns out wood-fired pizzas.
Italian menus tend to be regional and seasonal, with smaller plates and pasta served as its own course. Italian-American cooking grew up in U.S. immigrant kitchens and leans on long-simmered red sauce, bigger portions and shared plates. In Orlando, Ravello and Primo lean Italian, Osteria Ester and Prato are modern takes on Italian-American, and spots like Il Pescatore and Christini's keep the traditional style.
Looking for something to do? Check out Things To Do This Weekend or See What's Happening Today.
